Posted on 08/09/2008 3:50:28 AM PDT by abb
War in and of itself is horrific. My point is that once undertaken, you had better be prepared to do whatever it takes to finish it successfully. And I don't think it necessary to apologize. For the record Nagasaki was an important military target.
"The city of Nagasaki had been one of the largest sea ports in southern Japan and was of great wartime importance because of its wide-ranging industrial activity, including the production of ordnance, ships, military equipment, and other war materials."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki
Another thing. If we don't take off the kid gloves and show the Islamists just how ruthless a people we can be, the terror attacks will NEVER stop.
Here, we agree.
The two bombs saved a million lives.
I think that number is conservative!
Among others, the bombs saved an estimated 300,000 Allied POW's who were ordered to be executed the minute an invasion was launched.
Let us also not forget the Japanese were working on their own weapons of mass destruction -- primarily biological -- through facilities such as Unit 731. There is virtually no doubt this horror would have been unleashed on the United States had the Japanese been able. The bombs prevented that tragedy.
R. J. Rummel, a professor of political science at the University of Hawaii, states that between 1937 and 1945, the Japanese military murdered from nearly 3,000,000 to over 10,000,000 people, most probably 6,000,000 Chinese, Indonesians, Koreans, Filipinos, and Indochinese, among others, including Western prisoners of war. This democide was due to a morally bankrupt political and military strategy, military expediency and custom, and national culture." According to Rummel, in China alone, during 1937-45, approximately 3.9 million Chinese were killed, mostly civilians, as a direct result of the Japanese operations and 10.2 millions in the course of the war.
Finally, it should be remembered the bombs put an end to other Japanese atrocities, beyond comprehension to most and too numerous to list.
Yes, don't start them. We don't start wars, but we sure as hell finish them (or at least we used to).
Civilians are the backbone of society, who says they are ALL innocent anyways. Some accept the evil that government does, some even worship a human “sun god” they never seen or heard, some civilians even though don't pick up a weapon approve the actions of those that do. Some (minority) resist the evil that some governments do and either fight internally or become a martyr for resistance. In the end the real truth gets us in the end (And yes there is truth out there despite what moral relativist say).
First time I have heard of a personal experience seeing the flash. Bless your mom.
I live next to Hanford, WA, where the fuel for that weapon was manufactured but don’t take any pleasure in that fact and would never glorify the bombs. I Hope she is right that other lives were saved.
Yep. Compare Nagasaki to 'events' in Iraq that have lead to court martial. Pathetic!
When did the world come up with this limited response idea, that you're not supposed to hit the enemy back harder than they hit you?
If folks don't wake up, PC will literally be the death of us.
"If you ain't willin' to go all in, you ain't playin' to win."
Thanks for the information that even our government isn’t willing to face or teach in statist schools.
Also the word celebrate should not be used in any manner such as this. Remembrance that humanity hopefully would never go this route again is better.
And that includes Allied POWs, who I read somewhere, were dying at the rate of 1,000 per day. I use that figure when I run into those who said that the submarine war has choked off Japan's imports and they would have had to surrender "soon". They have no answer when I ask how many more thousand POWs must die while waiting for the collapse.
Then there's the story of a Jap diplomat who told an American that they surrendered because they didn't want any more bombs dropped. When told the Nagasaki bomb was our last, he said "If we'd known you had only two . . ." and then shut up, but the inference was clear they would have STILL held out.
Please note, I do not have a bone to pick in this arguement: the dropping of the second atomic bomb at Nagasaki, indirectly saved my Mother’s-(Japanese/Hometown-Place of Birth: Fukuoka) life and my Late Father-(American, was a young child, so he could not fight). What I object to strongly is the word: Happy to describe this occasion, there is nothing happy about it. Please try to understand where I am coming from, as this is a sensitive subject for me. My Mother lived through the air raids and bombings and was taught day in and day out that Americans were evil and the enemy, but hate did not cripple her mind, heart or soul for years later she married my Late Father, an American. They were married for thirty-five years and loved each other very much despite severe objections from my Late Fathers side: they did not want their only son marrying a dirty Jap. Well my Late Father loved my Mother very much, so he went against his parents wishes and married my Mother and they were happily married for thirty-five years until he passed away from a massive heart attack in 1995./Just Asking - seoul62........
"A special project code-named Maruta used human beings for experiments. Test subjects were gathered from the surrounding population and were sometimes referred to euphemistically as "logs" (丸太, maruta?).[9] This term originated as a joke on the part of the staff due to the fact that the official cover story for the facility given to the local authorities was that it was a lumber mill.[10]The test subjects were selected to give a wide cross section of the population, and included common criminals, captured bandits and anti-Japanese partisans, political prisoners, and also people rounded up by the secret police for alleged "suspicious activities" and included infants, the elderly, and pregnant women."
This FR post is interesting, because I recently saw an other Russell Crowe movie that had a character that had a former US Marine who had been a photographer that went in after the bomb was dropped on Nagasaki - "Rough Magic"
God bless your parents!
Thanks for the fantastic link information! How in the world did you come up with that? Are you living and working nearby? Was this information you came across at some point through somebody living back then?
I looked over the image and zoomed in close. The building certainly seem to be about WWII vintage and they would’ve held thousands and thousands of bodies. Rather grim place - I hope they warehouse more cheerful goods today.
Thanks again!
Thank you, you are welcome./Just Asking - seoul62.......
YOU ARE NUTS. I SAID NONE OF THE THINGS YOU ARE ACCUSING ME OF. JUST THE OPPOSITE.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.