[jwalsh07]

And if a detainee can be held without a right to a habeas proceeding where do you get to claim that you are a citizen? No right to file in any court because the military claims you are an enemy combatant is no right to file. It is in the resulting habeas hearing that you get to claim that you are US citizen. Get it?

I get that you are a liberal puke who thinks being a member of the United States military means violating your oath to the constitution every chance you get. We entrust our COmmanders to kill bad guys but we can't trust them to check dteainees citizenship claims? Horses manure all over that strawman.

I also get that you raise idiotic strawman arguments because the facts aren't your friend. Only liberal pukes claim that the US military would hold citizens unconstitutionally.

Like you.

And btw, I don't care if you've served, lot's of folks have served who make idiotic liberal arguments. So if that shoe fits...

[AndyJackson]

You didn’t read the case did you? Exactly what one of the detainees was denied was the right to prove he was not a member of Al Qaida.

[AndyJackson]

I get that you are a liberal puke who thinks being a member of the United States military means violating your oath to the constitution every chance you get.

You can goddamned well tell me right now what oath you are accusing me of violating.

Since Robert Gates has called for shutting down Guantanamo are you accusing him of violating his oath too?

[AndyJackson]

I am waiting for you to tell me what oath I have violated.