There are only two choices here Jackson, either Scalia is factually wrong in that paragraph or you're a liberal pimping for the liberals on the court.
Your move becuase the lease agreement is clear, GITMO is sovereign to Cuba.
I already said it. Scalia is factually wrong. I disagree with Scalia on a lot of things. While he claims to be an originalist, he is very quick to defer to stare decisis and legislative and executive prerogatives when he doesn't actually like where adherence to the original intent of the constitution would force him to go.