[rmlew]

Have you gone through the radio transcripts?

Also, please justify a Swordfish strike on the HMS Shefield by pilots from the HMS Ark Royal and thousands of other friendly fire incidents, since you think that the fog of war doesn't exist.

[Jonah Johansen]

How could anyone not believe in the fog of war, my point was that - at one time I thought a plausible explanation was the fog of war. The additional information brought up in the article I started this thread with makes me think that the fog of war is far less likely an explanation.

As has been pointed out by others, no one has ever come up with a reason for the attack, which if intentional would seem to justify the risk.