[Cyropaedia]

No they are not. Osvaldo Aldrete Davila is as guilty as sin.

Read Mark Brewer's brief to the Fifth Circuit before you shoot off your mouth :

Here.

[highball]

Osvaldo Aldrete Davila is as guilty as sin.

That doesn't mean that the agents aren't also guilty. It's not an either/or.

Did the agents lie about the shooting? Everything I've read says yes, they did. And if so, then they aren't the good guys - this situation wouldn't have any.

No free nation can abide crooked cops. Ever. Under any circumstances.

[curiosity]

No they are not. Osvaldo Aldrete Davila is as guilty as sin.

As another reader pointed out, all three parties are guilty of a crime. Davila is guilty of smuggling drugs. Compean and Ramos are guilty of shooting an unarmed man in the back, lying about it, and tampering with evidence.

Read Mark Brewer's brief to the Fifth Circuit before you shoot off your mouth

Who exactly is Mark Brewer, and why exactly should I take his opinion as authoritative?

I've looked at the facts for myself, thank you very much. I don't need some yahoo to interpret them for me.