Dad's may not be much on the tenderness and affection thing, but the comfort she could have gotten from her father was the satisfaction of watching him beat them to a bloody pulp when he found out what happened.
I'm thinking back to when I was that age and I know I would have wanted my mom if it came down to a choice between the two.
I'm sure my brother would have wanted our dad, though.
For all the talk of rape and sexual abuse and stuff...I don't agree but I will agree that this was a huge invasion of personal privacy that would really be tough to experience, especially for a child. :( Poor thing.