[mamelukesabre]

Oh, I’d argue that strenuously. I’d call a 44 henry rimfire a silly round. I don’t care if you got a thousand of them stashed away. You got no business shooting them or relying on them for self defense. Power level has nothing to do with it. It’s the obsolescence and age and reliability of the powder. Not to mention, the collector value is such that shooting them is just dumb.

[Dead Corpse]

It's zero-dark:30. You hear a noise downstairs. The only thing you have to defend yourself with is either your bare hands, or that antique Henry rimfire.

What do you choose?

End of argument...