both can easily be marxist.
(event with your confusion as to years and marx’s life)
this is not a either or situation. BOTH are bad.
grow up.
Not one person has defended or said the current system is good. This fair tax scam is insanely wrong.
The proposal is a falure with the flaws disected and exosing the plan as seriously wanting.
Dump HR 25 and start again.
The alegation of 20 million being spent to examine this has been shown to be a sham.
The organizations headquarters is a hole in the wall office in houston texas.
The redistribution embeded in HR 25 with the rebate/prebate is an entitlement via wealth redistribution.
“....both can easily be marxist.”
Then why was only an income tax specified in “The Communist Manifesto”? Are you saying that you know more about Marxism than Karl Marx?