Posted on 01/20/2008 6:29:07 AM PST by Man50D
Under FT, they pay nothing. Hence all those who live at home in the basement are strongly attracted to the FT (along with drug dealers and others who don't want to report their income).
"Lastly, a VAT is a lobbyist’s dream, allowing them to install their loopholes unbeknownst to the purchaser." --FairTax.org
The Fair Tax spammers are having trouble keeping their talking points straight.
By the way,,,do you make a living directly or indirectly from the current income tax system?”
I don’t understand the question.
One that politicians love. All sorts of 'rats want a VAT "just like Europe".
Have you ever been employed by the Fed gov’t, as say being in the military?;-) Yes, it’s a stupid question.
“Your life saving are simply acceptable collateral damage on the path to monthly federal stipends for everyone. Surely you wouldn’t want to stand in the way of the coming utopia?” The FTers are doing it “for the children”. You against little kids?
I don’t understand the question.(Proud2BeRight)
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Yes, you do.
Do you get a paycheck or monetary income ( directly or indirectly) in any form because the current IRS system exists?
Wanna tell me what the constitution say about income taxes?
Do you also want to explain to me the dif between “freemen” and “Freeman”?
You might have to study colonial common law on that one.
considering how the HR 25 bill allows the GOVERNMENT to define legally approved families. The sexual recreation lobby will work overtime to go heather has two mommies/two daddies.
Big Brother Loves You.
No sales taxes in any state are "tax inclusive". Why? Because people are not stupid.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Obviously all government employees receive tax income. They would STILL receive tax income from the Fair Tax as well.
However...under the current IRS system there are ARMIES of accountants, lawyers, payroll tax firms, tax prep services, and whole departments of some large industries are dedicated to managing IRS taxes.
Do you, Paladin2 and Proud2BeRight benefit directly or indirectly from the IRS collection, management, law advice, or tax preparation, or any other form of handling IRS taxes?
The Constitution (as currently construed) says YOU are pw3|\|d
by the Feds.
Do you get a refund check each year?
The only part of this proposal that will survive will be the monthly check.
Your suggestion is unworkable as trying to have one communist system (fair tax) overlay with the capitalist system.
The IRS must go, but the Fairscammers are so delusionally invested in this specific proposal that they can not see of some OTHER way to achieve all our mutual goals.
I think you've covered it, Don Quixote. You may return to tilting at tax windmills now.
Or the debit card.
I suspect that a case could be made that EVERYBODY in the US can be shown to "benefit" indirectly from the IT. It's still a stupid question. Sorry.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
You are being deliberately obtuse.
It is really a simple question.
Do you, Paladin2 benefit directly or indirectly from the ***business and occupation**** of IRS collection, IRS management, IRS law advice, or IRS tax preparation, or any other form of handling and managing IRS taxes?
Under the current IRS system there are ARMIES of accountants, lawyers, payroll tax firms, tax prep services, and whole departments of some large industries are dedicated to managing IRS taxes. EVERYONE of these people would have their livelihoods threatened by a Fair Tax.
Most are against it because they fear change, They fear that they might have to actually pay a constitutionally LEGAL tax.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.