[jwalsh07]

You're filaments open pal which is why you're not one of the brighter bulbs I've met here of late.

Scalia is explaining why the liberals in Rasul were FOS. You support the liberals. Follow that to it's logical conclusion.

[Tlaloc]

The Supreme Court have ruled that the Geneva Conventions apply to detainees at Gitmo! The Bush administration acquiesced and ordered that all the detainees shall be treated according to the Geneva convention.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/11/AR2006071100455.html

The fact is that Gitmo IS within the territorial jurisdiction of US courts, and the President must obey their decisions, as he has! He has not kept these detainees from being protected by the Supreme Court, and he cannot!