I agree with everything you have said. McFadden deserves it, although I do think Tebow is a Freak, and at the college level anyways, is simply amazing. Having said that, if the Oregon QB doesn’t get hurt, I’d have to consider him over Tebow as well.
I’d still consider him. With Dixon, Oregon is possibly the top team in the country, and should be playing in the National Championship game. Without him, they aren’t even in the top 50.
the Oregon QB was hurt, season ending, during their Arizona game. He was a viable contender before that.