[MississippiMan]

But it will be a shame if McFadden doesn’t win the Heisman. I’ve never seen anyone like him. He will dominate at the next level... OTOH, Tebow will have to develop a new style of play if he wants to survive the NFL. He won’t be able to take off and run over people like he does now.

McFadden is a great one, no doubt, but I think Tebow deserves the Heisman. His NFL prospects are not supposed to have anything to do with; after all, they gave the Heisman to Jason White in 2003 while all the time acknowledging that he wasn't good enough to go pro. Utterly stupid IMHO; if you're not good enough to go pro, how can you possibly be the best collegiate football player?

Waxing nostalgic, Herschel Walker remains the most incredible college running back I've ever personally watched live.

MM (in TX)

[Uncle Ivan]

Tebow doesn't deserve the Heisman over McFadden. You could take most any mobile QB, put him in Florida's system, and he'd have good stats.

Notice that McFadden has been winning awards from former players and coaches, while Tebow has been getting his from media members. Says it all.