[edsheppa]

I was please when Coyoteman accepted my challenge, but disappointed when he tried to change the rules after failing to make the grade.

False. You permitted inductive reasoning and that's what he did.

[Frumious Bandersnatch]

Oh but he did. The Coyoteman tried to change it to a scientific discussion. He also posed it as an evolution vs. ID debate. Rather than defend any of his assumptions, he presented them as dogma without any logical debate.

Plus, he was a bit guilty of being somewhate selective of his facts concerning the debates in the19th and 20th centuries. But all of that was beside the point, because it had nothing to do with the logic of the underlying assertion. It was all noise and had no logical point to the challenge I offered.

I grant you that he tried to use induction, but not very effectively. Besides, he is a three exclamation point evolutionists, and therefore is disqualified from using anything other than deduction (because he disallows it automatically from IDers).