Posted on 10/23/2007 4:54:36 PM PDT by NormsRevenge
NAPLES, Fla. - Republican Fred Thompson said Tuesday the government should yank federal dollars from cities and states that don't report illegal immigrants.
In his first major policy proposal, Thompson challenged presidential rivals Rudy Giuliani and Mitt Romney by criticizing "sanctuary cities" where city workers are barred from reporting suspected illegal immigrants who enroll their children in school or seek hospital treatment.
"Taxpayer money should not be provided to illegal immigrants," Thompson said at a round-table discussion that included Collier County, Fla., sheriff Don Hunter.
Thompson has argued his rivals are soft on illegal immigration because Giuliani, as New York mayor, sued the federal government to keep his city's sanctuary policy and because Romney tolerated sanctuary cities as Massachusetts' governor.
In turn, Giuliani's campaign accused Thompson of being weak on the issue. At a news conference Tuesday in Boston, Giuliani said: "I'm the one who can bring about immigration reform."
The immigration issue is important to many conservatives who influence Republican primaries. Some argue that illegal immigrants are straining schools and hospitals and taking jobs from U.S. citizens.
Thompson chose to announce his plan in Collier County, which has vast tomato farms that hire thousands of immigrants and last year was part of a two-county sweep that saw 163 illegal immigrants arrested in one weekend.
Thompson's campaign said 22 percent of the county's crime is committed by illegal immigrants.
To the sheriff, Thompson said: "You've clearly been swamped with a particular kind of problem because the federal government, in large part, has let you down and has not done their part."
"There's not a lot of new legislation that needs to be passed," the candidate said. "We need to enforce the laws that are on the books. There are laws against illegal immigration, there are laws to secure the border, there are laws against sanctuary cities, there are laws against publicly funding illegals, and that law is being disregarded."
Under Thompson's plan, sanctuary cities would lose discretionary federal grants, as would colleges and universities that allow illegal immigrants to pay in-state tuition.
The former Tennessee senator also called for stronger laws forcing employers to verify that workers aren't illegal immigrants, for a more rigorous system to track who is coming in and out of the country and for increased prosecution of "coyotes," smugglers who bring illegal immigrants across the Mexican border.
Calling for stronger border security, he said: "A small amount of nuclear material could do a lot of damage in the wrong hands. It makes you wonder why a terrorist would bother going through an airport or a port ... when we have an open border."
"In 1996 we passed a bill, I was in the Senate, that outlawed sanctuary city cities. Mayor Giuliani went to court to defeat that law," Thompson said.
Giuliani spokeswoman Katie Levinson said Thompson didn't try to fix the problem of illegal immigration when he was in the Senate.
"He was voting against $1 billion to combat illegal immigration at the borders, against stricter employment verification and for giving illegal immigrants more benefits than we give legal immigrants. That's not consistent or conservative," Levinson said.
Romney spokesman Kevin Madden called Thompson a latecomer to the issue of sanctuary cities. "Governor Romney has been the strongest candidate when it comes to demanding that our existing immigration laws are enforced," Madden said.
Romney has spent several weeks criticizing Giuliani for New York's sanctuary policy; Giuliani responds that he cracked down on all lawlessness and that Romney tolerated sanctuary cities in Massachusetts.
Romney says he tried to curtail the problem by deputizing state police to enforce federal immigration laws.
Romney and Giuliani both are calling for tougher border security and enforcement of immigration laws, although in the past they spoke favorably of measures, sponsored by Arizona Sen. John McCain, another rival, that would provide a path to citizenship for the estimated 12 million immigrants here illegally.
As Thompson traveled through Florida, his campaign suffered another staff departure and lost a key supporter in New Hampshire to rival John McCain.
Aides confirmed that Nelson Warfield, a political media strategist, has left the campaign while New Hampshire Republican Dan Hughes said he had joined McCain's campaign leadership team.
Hughes, a developer who helped Ronald Reagan's campaign in 1980 and later Reagan's White House transition team, publicly split from the Thompson campaign last week, citing Thompson's lack of interest in the early voting state.
___
Associated Press Writer Libby Quaid and Liz Sidoti reported from Washington, and Jay Lindsay contributed from Boston.
No matching “FRed” funds for sanctuary cities and states that don’t report illegal immigrants.
Sign me up.
Republican presidential hopeful, former Tennessee Sen. Fred Thompson, smiles as he answers questions from the media while touring the Urbieta Oil Company, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007, in Medley, Fla. (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee)
Smile, FRed. You're on Candid Camera! ;-)
Ditto That.I would support Fred ifonly for his stand on illegal immigration.Thats not to say he does’nt have valid ideas in other areas.
Thompson is right!
All the FRed skeptics around here, from back before the purge, were railing on and on about his immigration stance, not that they ever bothered to read anything he put up about it back then; I would hope they get the picture now.
Naw, they will still dredge up old articles as if it was gospel. They refuse to face facts, their guy is going nowhere fast. And the one who is in the lead is about to get a wake up call.
Keep it up Fred!
FRed's just been tuning his guitar. He's fix'n to let her rip.
And I don’t remember Romney doing much to stop the sanctuary cities in MA.
So Rootie and Romney can talk all day. But FRed’s the man with a plan.
I wish he would bring Immigration to the forefront in Conservative conversation. A lot of people would pay attention.
Hit pieces from the enemedia are a pretty reliable indicator of which candidates they fear the most. I’ve noticed the hit pieces on Rudi Guilani have been pretty scarce lately.
Fred's idea of withholding federal funds from sanctuary cities is not original, but it is a very good start. Another excellent step would be to exclude illegal immigrants from the counts of states and localities for the purposes of apportionment. This would get the rust belt on your side. Rep. Candice Miller of Michigan has just such a bill before congress. The first of the top tier candidates to start pushing it earns my vote. Until then, I'll continue to support Duncan Hunter.
[snip}
The amendment by Sen. Vitter (R-La.) would deny a popular federal police grant to cities that adopt "sanctuary" policies. These are policies that prohibit police from reporting illegal aliens to the feds.
If the amendment passes, it is unlikely that any city would give up the federal funding in order to continue to provide sanctuary to illegal aliens.
Generally, sanctuary policies instruct city employees not to notify the federal government of the presence of illegal aliens living in their communities. The policies also end the distinction between legal and illegal immigration--so illegal aliens often benefit from city services too.
It was defeated!
“I wish he would bring Immigration to the forefront in Conservative conversation. A lot of people would pay attention.”
I think...he just did. :)
The rest of 'em are just going to be 'me too' also rans....
I’m votin’ fer Fred...
I am so sick of the limp posture on illegals. Duncan Hunter and Tom Tancredo are on the list for a vote...
The rest are either full of doggy doo or tap dance around too much on the issue...
True,because rudy spells reform, a-m-n-e-s-t-y.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.