Posted on 10/09/2007 8:05:17 PM PDT by Politicalmom
Here's what was said, from the official transcript. I'm including McCain's prior comments because Thompson kicked off his response by saying that McCain had it right in this situation:
Matthews: ...that raises the question, if you were president of the United States, would you need to go to Congress to get authorization to take military action against Iran's nuclear facilities?
McCain: We're dealing, of course, with hypotheticals. If the situation is that it requires immediate action to ensure the security of the United States of America, that's what you take your oath to do, when you're inaugurated as president of the United States.
If it's a long series of build-ups, where the threat becomes greater and greater, of course you want to go to Congress; of course you want to get approval, if this is an imminent threat to the security of the United States of America.
So it obviously depends on the scenario.
But I would, at minimum -- I would, at minimum, consult with the leaders of Congress because there may come a time when you need the approval of Congress. And I believe that this is a possibility that is, maybe, closer to reality than we are discussing tonight.
Mr. Matthews: Senator Thompson?
Mr. Thompson: On this question? Yes, I think John has it right.
I would add that under the War Powers Act, there's always a conflict between the Congress and the president as to the exact applicability of that when an engagement lasts for a particular period of time and when they must come before Congress.
I don't think anybody running for president should diminish the power of the office before he gets there and take side in a hypothetical dispute. But I would say that in any close call, you should go to Congress, whether it's legally required or not. Because you're going to need the American people and Congress will help you if they're voting for it or if they support it, or leaders, especially in the opposite party, are convinced and looking at the evidence that this is the right thing to do, that will help you with the American people.
Mr. Thompson: And we have learned that, over the long term in any conflict, we've got to have the strong support of the American people over a protracted period of time.
Thanks for putting it in context ellery!
Care to make a detraction byteback?
I need to go to bed! Sleep is imperative!
I meant:
Care to make a retraction byteback?
That is great. Gee, for someone who's lazy, doesn't really want it, and whose campaign is in complete turmoil, his people seem to be quick and on the ball.
Yes you do..., when it is REALLY BROWN, you can kick it around (without much danger of having it stick to your boot)!
CheyennePress wrote: “You honestly believe Fred Thompson won that debate??”
More than a few people do. National Review’s Kathryn Jean Lopez, for example: “And the Winner Is...Fred Thompson.”
http://corner.nationalreview.com/post/?q=NDM2OGIwZjU5ZGRmMjAxMzQ2ZWJiOWIzYWFlMzUyYzQ=
One point of disagreement: McCain did faulter and repeat himself at a crucial point in an important answer. His mind is not as sharp as it needs to be in order to function at the level of President.
Yeah, Fred answered correctly but that's the type of tactic that should get Chrissy kneed in the nuts at the next cocktail party.
“Jeri Thompson is about half country herself, she comes from Naperville, Illinois, that’s not shanty town but it’s a ways down the road from affluent Park Ridge where Hillary comes from.”
Geez, whoever wrote this doesn’t know Illinois and specifically doesn’t know Naperville. I live two towns over from Naperville. It is a huge town, I believe it is now third or fourth largest in size in Illinois population-wise. I lived in Naperville for a while in one of my previous incarnations. What a charming place to be. It has the double pleasure of being a quaint historical town founded in the mid-1830’s along the DuPage River in rich fertile soil (Illinois has the most beautiful black earth, but I digress), with lovely trees and a wonderful location (about 35 miles west of Chicago). Along what is known as the highway I-88 corridor, one high tech business after another has sprung up. The town grew by leaps and bounds, and is chock full of wealthy entrepreneurs as well as lots of middle class families, and tons of kids. The school system is excellent, the tax base great (an artsy craftsy downtown area with lots of little shops and many restaurants), and a beautiful riverwalk. In comparison, Park Ridge is a well healed but rather bland and gray town with 1/2 the charm of Naperville. But to make Jeri out as being some kind of hick from the sticks is a baldface lie of the first order. Anyone who wants to check out Naperville, go to its website and see for yourself:
MONEY Magazine: Best places to live 2006: Naperville, IL
WINNER
Naperville, IL
Top 100 rank: 2
Population: 141,600
Go to this link and see for yourself what Naperville is all about:
http://www.naperville.il.us/community_relations_visiting_naperville.aspx
“Overview
Each year, millions of people visit Naperville to enjoy our unique blend of big-city amenities and small-town charm. Naperville’s quaint downtown offers an array of shopping, dining and cultural activities to fit every budget. From well-known retail stores to unique boutiques, Naperville’s eclectic mix of shops beckons even the most hesitant shopper.
World-class parks and unique cultural opportunities make Naperville the destination of choice for both residents and visitors. On a nice day, thousands of people come into town to stroll along the picturesque Riverwalk, frolic at Centennial Beach or enjoy a free outdoor concert.
Naperville also offers a number of year-round attractions including museums, theaters, public art and performance groups. Don’t forget to check out the many community events around town during the year. Use the Quick Links to the right to explore more of what Naperville has to offer.”
oops, healed = heeled in above comment.
Sounds like a town where i would like to live ... not presumptuous, middle class, uncomplicated, populated by working folk. Yeah, sounds like the type of town where I’d like to live.
Sounds like a town where i would like to live ... not presumptuous, middle class, uncomplicated, populated by working folk. Yeah, sounds like the type of town where I’d like to live.
That was reaction to a sinus drip that started with entry into Michigan.
uhhh...I believe the brown stuff is dirt, not dodo.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.