Daily Kos: General Petraeus Wore Fraudulent Medal

Here are just a few of the post by you where you are clearly trying to impugned the General's right to the award. That despite the fact all the information on it had been posted to you by various Freepers. Now that you have had your face rubbed in your error, you are desperately trying to rewrite history rather then simply admit you were wrong. Rather then continue to spin desperately for some hair splitting rational to avoid admitting error, just deal with it. You were wrong.

Post 21

Some of the guys I drill with were wondering about his CAB (Combat Action Badge) as combat badges are not generally awarded to General officers. I am not really certain as to what the regulation is about awarding the CAB though, but perhaps this is what the Kossacks are refering to. Post 43 Haig never wore a CAB as it is a new award that has only been awarded since the start of the GWOT. He probably wore a CIB (Combat Infantryman’s Badge) which he earned as a junior officer in WWII (or Korea). Patraeus may have been awarded the CAB-I am unsure of the regulation-but combat badges are generally not awarded to senior officers.

Post 47

I am not sure what AR 60-8-22 says about the CAB. I believe that it says that the CMB is not to be awarded to officers above the rank of Colonel-and says the same about the CIB. There may not be any similar restriction on award of the CAB, but that is the only thing I can think of that might apply (other than the Kossacks being full of crap).

Post 58

I think it is infinitely more likely that he earned the BSM with V in a previous conflict as he was a division commander in Iraq and probably wasn’t as likely to be in position to show valor (commanders usually have a PSD to protect them). As I said, some of the guys I drill with were wondering about the CAB-I am unsure about the requirements under the regulation.

Post 67

I’m tracking-see my reply 47. I personally know soldiers who served a full tour in Iraq whose CAB was denied for what I think were trivial interpretations of the regulation. Because of that, I think it is entirely appropriate to ask questions when I see a General officer wearing it.

Post 162

I understand. I am not personally eligible for the CAB (instead I have been awarded the CMB). However, when we were deployed several of the soldiers attached to our squadron were denied their CAB in cases that were never adequately explained (for instance two of the guys in a HWMMV that was hit by an IED got it while the other two did not). It makes me raise an eyebrow to see a General officer wearing it.

fyi, when i was a "part-time" (what a grim JOKE the "part-time" turned out to be!!! it was a 24/365 job.) city marshal in the late 60s (i was in college at that time & POOR enough to do most ANYTHING to finish school), i investigated a "suspicious death" in which it was FINALLY figured out that an elderly man shot himself 2 times in the chest (which OBVIOUSLY didn't kill him!) and ONCE in the mouth with a .410 shotgun (which DID!!!).

caused me "no end of aggravation" trying to figure out WHAT exactly happened, as i never thought that a SUICIDE could take THREE shots. (a forensic physician/specialist at the State Crime Lab PROVED the "sequence of events".)

after 30+ years of civil/military law enforcement/investigations, NOTHING much surprises me any more!!!

there's a LOT of REALLY peculiar things that happen "out there". (as a diarist of the 19th Century said: "There are many things, which if written as fiction, would expose the author to PUBLIC RIDICULE;on the other hand, NOTHING is so ODD that it could NOT have actually happened".)

free dixie,sw

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.