Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Jeff Head; Enchante; JasonC; Millee; carlr; Maximus of Texas; EX52D; StephenTX; wallcrawlr; ...
Re: But the facts are, as I have indicated from the start, that the SU-30s that Chavez has bought pose a serious threat to the UK task force and that that task force would be in there range and require US help. The Venezuelans have had refueling capability for something like 40 years I believe, and one of the major selling points of the SU30s they bought (among others, including anti-shipping missile capability) is its inflight refueling capability which gives it the range to pose the threat.

Sorry, but "...the facts are, as I have indicated from the start..." did not include air-to-air refueling capability of Hugo's air force. That was brought up later. This began with your 102 post: "If we do not provide that help, then the UK, IMHO, in either case, would not be able to get past Venesuela on the way down to the Falklands."

Had you said instead: "If we do not provide that help, then the UK, IMHO, in either case, would not be able to get past air-to-air refueled Venezuelan SU-30s on the way down to the Falklands." there would not have been any comment by myself.

Matter of fact, "air-to-air refuelling" was not mentioned in the Times article and was first mentioned in this thread by britemp on post 144 in reference to RAF Typhoons flying to Ascension Island.

This will be my final comment on this matter and the last time I shall join any of Jeff Head's threads as he makes it clear you must either telepathically toe his line of thinking or not be in the approved loop...

When all this began, there had not been any mention of the Venezuelan Air Force air-to-air refueling asset. Only the 24 SU-30MK Chavez had purchased and their taking on a hypothetical British Naval Task Force on the way to the Falklands.

My reply was to the extent that any British Task Force would not pass anywhere close enough to Venezuela for the SU-30s to attack unless it was suicide flights.

It was said that the Brits were passing east of Hugoland, so they were in danger. Bringing air-to-air refueling into the conversation at this point makes that in the realm of possibility. Yet it could also be said with air-to-air refueling suddenly in the equation, Hugo’s air force could attack the Brit Task Force while it passed through the Suez Canal! Or as they rounded the Cape of Good Hope! Or even in the Thames as they gear up to leave...

My attempts at googling the following info is not the final authority, but it is the best I have been able to find at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_Air_Force http://www.scramble.nl/ve.htm
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/venezuela/airforce.htm

The best out-and-back range of the SU-30MK I could find was 3,000 km (1,620 nm). The mention of one KC-135 airtanker for Hugo’s air force comes from Jeff Head, my looking only gives mention of one 707 and mention of six C-130 transports and no mention of any of them having an air-to-air refueling ability.

Hypothetically we have a British Task Force leaving the UK and heading down to Ascension Island. Knowing of Hugo’s threat, they keep as close to the cost of Africa as possible to make their distance from Venezuela around 2,900 miles.

The art and ability to send out a bombing force to that range takes a great deal of assets and professionalism even with the USAF who train for this each and every day. To give that capability to Hugo’s air force with a single KC-135 type tanker, only 10 SU-30MK on hand today and 14 more expected in 2008 is a fantasy. No amount of money or hardware can instantly make a formidable force to fly out, attack an opposing naval fleet and expect to do significant damage and return the majority of your attack air craft. It take training over and over again a long time to be proficient in this.

Perhaps in a year or two if Hugo bought more airtankers and trained the devil out of his SU-30s, they may have a chance.

Now, tracking this fleet would fall to Russian spy satellites and the info passed on to Hugo.

So, given all this hypothetical hardware, training and tracking, I will admit it is a slim possibility Hugo’s air force could take on the attack mission and make the Brits turn back as Jeff Head said in his humble opinion.

Yet, as it has been pointed out I clearly do not fathom the geographic situation and do not grasp the military situation, so I say, Jeff, go ahead (pun intended) and be the only one with any grasp of any hypothetical geographic/political/military situation any where, any place, any time...

You have taken one who once considered you a colleague, a friend, and, in short order, have stripped away any and all friendship and collegiality from them...

You, sir, may have floor for eternity and I say good bye and good riddance!

276 posted on 09/03/2007 9:06:05 AM PDT by Bender2 ("I've got a twisted sense of humor, and everything amuses me." RAH Beyond this Horizon)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 233 | View Replies ]


To: Bender2
Ah, so someone else was actually arguing the point. Didn't notice, and you are right.

Me, I'm just worried by (1) what Chazev will actually use his new forces for, which doesn't have anything to do with your hypothetical and (2) the lamentable draw-down of the royal navy, which was once a serious force for good in the world - and is now mostly a museum.

278 posted on 09/03/2007 9:29:00 AM PDT by JasonC
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 276 | View Replies ]

To: Bender2
Sorry you feel that way. In my mind, you have taken what amounts to a simple misunderstanding and miscommunication and blown it all out of proportion.

As I said earlier, for whatever it is worth, and for whatever part I had in the misunderstanding, I apologize and wish you the best in any case.

279 posted on 09/03/2007 10:57:25 AM PDT by Jeff Head
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 276 | View Replies ]

To: Bender2

“..the Venezuelan Air Force air-to-air refueling asset..”

There is a flying Citgo station?


299 posted on 09/03/2007 8:22:52 PM PDT by Rembrandt (We would have won Viet Nam w/o Dim interference.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 276 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson