Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: stand watie
“also, how do you “explain away” the TENTH AMENDMENT to the BOR, which states that those powers NOT CEDED to the federal government REMAIN the powers/RIGHTS of the STATES/PEOPLE???”

If you had read my post #869 the writer I sited covers this. Indeed your mentioning of “the people” supports the unconstitutionality of secession. The 10th amendment in limiting the power of the federal government gives sovereignty to TWO entities. One is the states, and the other is THE PEOPLE. Thats all the people of the whole nation as a single unit. It mentions the people as separate from the states. If you read my post you will see the framers felt that the federal government was answerable to THE PEOPLE and not to the states. The people as a whole(through the federal process), the whole nation, can only constitutionally allow states, groups of states, heck even parts of states from leaving the union. The writer goes on to explain how the civil war might have been classified a revolution but then does goes on to explain how it wasn’t.

897 posted on 09/10/2007 5:59:47 PM PDT by Delacon (When in doubt, ask a liberal and do the opposite.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 881 | View Replies ]


To: Delacon
The 10th amendment in limiting the power of the federal government gives sovereignty to TWO entities. One is the states, and the other is THE PEOPLE. Thats all the people of the whole nation as a single unit.

NO action requires unanimity of the states, the powers are to the states severally and independently. The same applies to the people - the people of the several states, not the entire people. Their is no action that the people of any state can perform for another state. The motion to submit the ratification of the Constitution to the amalgamated people did not even receive a second. Historical fact refutes the absuridty of that position.

901 posted on 09/10/2007 8:22:51 PM PDT by 4CJ (Annoy a liberal, honour Christians and our gallant Confederate dead)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 897 | View Replies ]

To: Delacon
actually, i read you post & understood it.

i just believe that you have been propagandized by the unionist fanatics.

the union was created as a "creature of" the STATES. (it is NOT the creation of the people.)

thus the STATES are still FREE to modify, withdraw from or abolish that union, at any time of their CHOOSING.

free dixie,sw

911 posted on 09/11/2007 7:37:09 AM PDT by stand watie ("Resistance to tyrants is OBEDIENCE to God." - T. Jefferson, 1804)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 897 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson