Brad Pitt looks like a wimp to me - just not attractive.
Pitt is a pretty boy...
When women see a tough and rough looking guy, like "Duncan MacCloud from the Clan MacCloud" type,(Adrian Paul) larger tougher guy, with real facial hair, with larger toned muscles which promises stamina, ( not peach fuzz, dainty legs and sickly looking like Brad Pitt) They have a vision of more physical, sweaty physically exhausting sex.
With the Brat Pitt types, women need to cover up with a warm blanket afterwards, because they feel a little chilled from being naked.
With the Adrian Paul types, they need to stay naked and turn on a fan to cool off.
Also, it's not only a conscious attraction, more of a subconscious chemical one, natural selection of the strongest (therefore healthier) over the weakest,(indicating sickly and weak.)
He’s not the least bit attractive. Way too feminine.