I thought he was a bad actor...
Remember years ago on some big media story he almost got charges pressed against him for getting into a cat fight with a woman over a parking place.
Shep is a anchorman not a journalist.
When he very first came on FOX I was so impressed by his great grooming and looks even though I prefer blonde butterschotch/blue eyes or carmel/green eyes.
Then the rumors started that he was light in the loafers. Poof! The fantasy gone.
I thought he was a bad actor...