No, the problem is you're criticizing the BOOKS based on the MOVIES. If you want to talk about the book, read the book. If you want to talk about the movie, watch the movie. If you'd actually read the books you're talking about, you wouldn't be getting so much flak.
“If you want to talk about the movie, watch the movie. If you’d actually read the books you’re talking about, you wouldn’t be getting so much flak.”
My point all along has been that HP, whether book or movie, contains real occultic practice. I think the quote from JKR in post #912 now proves that beyond any dispute.