Posted on 07/26/2007 10:56:25 AM PDT by Red in Blue PA
On and on we can go, arguing that every single plant and animal on earth would be better off if humans weren't around. And after humans, the next predator in line, and so on and so forth. eventually the entire earth would be devoid of all life except one single plant.
We are part of the food chain, get used to it.
A “food chain” doesn’t involve killing animals and leaving their bodies behind without eating a single bite of them. Nor would it make a bit of sense for one species in the food chain to cause the extinction of a species it depends on for food..
The population of Africa is 688 million. according to the AIDS pandemic reported over the past 10 years, Africans should be next to non- existent. Or, the population of Africa was uncountable ten years ago. The AIDS claims just don't add up to being anywhere near believable. It's just another UN/NGO cash cow
No leap of logic THERE ...
Yup.
Yep. They're just animals too.
Nope. Not nearly enough money.
I agree. that’s why I’m a conservationist. We have to ensure we keep our food supply healthy and in abundance. Any practices which would put those things we rely on in danger of depletion beyond recovery should be eliminated.
The senseless killing of these gorilla’s is just that.
Maybe so, but if anyone is to judge my soul, it ain't gonna be YOU.
Well, one of us is ...
That only seems fair. I don't care about yours.
... when it’s one that if widely adopted will spoil things for thinking people I take note.
"If widely adopted ..." Do you mean if more people don't care about the deaths of four apes? And by "thinking people" I take it you don't include yourself ...
WHERE did I say it WAS my job? I gave you a quote. And added to it. If it stung, it was the correct quote and response.
Good for them. Do you think that means they are human? Or that they are gorillas? Or that there is any logical link between this story and that anecdotal fact?
And their handlers would probably tell you that the animals have more humanity than most humans.
Then their handlers have spent too much time in the kennel. Anthropomorphization is not unusual in people who spend a lot of time with animals, but it is still a psychological dysfunction.
You opinion is, putting it nicely, very sick.
... said the guy who thinks doggies are people too.
Is killing a gorilla (a potential human)as bad as killing an unborn baby? Just wondering.
I agree. The deaths of four of these apes does not constitute extinctive depletion. Senseless, apparently, but not likely to eradicate the whole species.
I like hunting deer and moose, but also am active to protect the health and abundance of the herds so I can continue to hunt and eat them.
No such value accrues to the animals in question. Not that that justifies slaughtering them wholesale, but I don't think four deaths is exactly eradication.
How is a gorilla a potential human? Are you saying one day it will turn into a human?
A gorilla is an animal. A beast like all other animals.
Some people call insects animals these days. They aren’t they are bugs.
Anyways, if Gorilla’s are now humans, and insects are now animals, That must mean us former humans must have moved up a level as well; are we now God’s?
Your “addition” included the phrase “Seems to me ...” I took that to mean that your were applying the quote to me, and that in doing so you were casting a judgment. In fact, I’m not sure you can really argue otherwise and be honest.
If you read my tag line you would understand my sarcasm. (evolution)
Is killing anything that's helpless right? Disregard for animals as living things that feel pain leads to callousness towards humans.
"A man's soul can be judged by the way he treats his dog." -Charles Doran
Seems to me that that would include anything that's helpless, child or animal.
Someone mentioned trained dogs used in the war. Yes indeed, they saved lives, but it wasn't out of "love" or emotional reasoning. It's was strictly out of learned behavior, training. My dog will fetch a stick no mater where I throw it. If I tossed it into a volcano, the dog would probably jump in after it. (Out of love of course.../s)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.