Could this be considered a violation of the First Amendment? I can almost see the ACLU panting at the door. It could set a precedent that could come back to bite us. How long would it be before liberals wanted Free Republic shut down?
Other than that, I think it's a great idea.
In the mind of traitors yes it is a violation of the first amendment but of course they are totally wrong as usual. Telling people to kill Americans, recruiting people for terrorism, and teaching them how to do terrorist attacks do not fall under the first amendment none whatsoever.
The government agencies can have more difficult time to shut a terrorist website because of "procedural stuff" and obstacles of "legalities" than regular folks like you and me pressuring the internet provider to shut the terrorist website or forum.