Posted on 07/05/2007 11:34:16 AM PDT by Bronco_Buster_FweetHyagh
The mother of a San Luis Obispo man who died after an attempted organ donation at Sierra Vista Regional Medical Center last year claims she never gave hospital officials consent to take her son off life-support and was misinformed when agreeing to the organ harvest, according to a wrongful death lawsuit.
Rosa Navarro also alleges in her June 29 civil lawsuit that a transplant surgeon misrepresented himself as her son’s doctor, an allegation the surgeon’s attorney strongly denies. She also said she agreed to the organ donation only because she believed her son had no chance of survival.
Defendants in the lawsuit — the San Luis Obispo hospital; its parent company, Dallas-based Tenet Corp.; the California Transplant Donor Network; transplant physicians Hootan Roozrokh and Arturo Martinez; and their employer, The Permanente Medical Group Inc.—are accused of assault, battery, fraud, civil conspiracy, negligence, medical malpractice and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Sierra Vista hospital on Tuesday denied any wrongdoing in the Feb. 4, 2006, death of 25-year-old Ruben Navarro.
Rosa Navarro, 54, is asking for unlimited compensation in the death of her son.
Ruben Navarro, who was dying of a rare metabolic disorder, had been on life support for four days and was expected to die. His mother agreed to donate his organs, and the California Transplant Donor Network dispatched its transplant team to Sierra Vista.
Rosa Navarro said during an interview from her Oxnard home Tuesday that when she arrived at the hospital she asked about her son’s condition. She said a hospital nurse told her to speak with the doctor.
“He came over and approached me and said I’m in charge of Ruben,” Navarro said of Roozrokh, who was part of the surgical team from San Francisco dispatched by Oakland-based Organ Transplant Donor Network.
“I asked him, ‘Doctor could you do anything for my boy?’ and he said, ‘Oh, no. Oh no… There’s nothing I can do for a patient like him.’ ”
Navarro said through sobs that Roozrokh asked her if she planned to watch him disconnect her son from life-support.
“He didn’t even ask me, ‘What do you want me to do Ms. Navarro? Do you want me to keep him on the machine or whatever?’ ” Navarro said.
Roozrokh’s attorney, M. Gerry Schwartzbach, told The Tribune on Tuesday that his client never spoke with Rosa Navarro and was not in charge of her son’s medical care.
“He did not have any conversation with her with regard to taking Ruben off the respirator. … Dr. Roozrokh was in the Bay Area,” Schwartzbach said. “I feel very bad for Ms. Navarro because she’s going through a great deal, but unfortunately someone misled her because she never met (Roozrokh) and she never spoke to him. That is absolutely clear.”
Schwartzbach said a local physician made the decision to remove Ruben Navarro from life support.
Ruben Navarro was brought into the operating room at 11 p.m. Feb. 3, 2006, and his breathing tube was removed. But he did not die within 30 minutes—the window during which organs could be harvested. He died nine hours later, according to the lawsuit.
An operating-room nurse reported that standard medical procedures weren’t followed when Navarro was taken off life support.
The lawsuit alleges Roozrokh ordered Ruben Navarro be given lethal doses of morphine and Ativan, an accusation also reported as a finding in a federal investigation by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
The report showed an intensive care nurse gave Ruben Navarro 220 milligrams of morphine and 80 milligrams of Ativan.
Sierra Vista spokesman Ron Yukelson did not respond to specific allegations against the hospital.
He did say a surgeon contracted with the donor network assumed responsibility for Navarro in violation of hospital policy, which requires a doctor to be credentialed by the hospital to treat a living patient.
District attorney’s investigators have been reviewing the case since March, but have made no decision about filing criminal charges.
“It’s a very unique case. No one’s prosecuted a case like this anywhere,” Assistant District Attorney Dan Hilford said Tuesday. “The case is very complex and deals with issues that require a great deal of research and study.”
State Medical Board spokeswoman Candis Cohen said the agency is investigating Roozrokh.
Martinez, the other doctor on the transplant team, could not be reached for comment.
“My mother taught me to keep my mouth shut if I couldn’t say anything nice. I don’t see anything nice about organ donation and it degrades with each one of these articles.”
I agreed to the harvesting of my daughter’s heart after she had been declared brain dead by three physicians.
I hope so too and that is why there is a great deal of oversight. No hospital or doctor wants to be accused of murder or sued for wrongful death. Organ donation saves lives and often provides some small comfort to the donor’s family.
Okay, let's talk about insurance. Should organs be given to people based on the best match or the best ability to pay? Should someone be allowed to die because they don't have insurance?
“Who on this thread has indicated a general opposition to organ donation?”
I dunno, read through the thread. Several people have stated that they would not sign an organ donor card. That’s certainly one way to make your own wishes on the subject known if the worst should happen. Of course, I’ve also informed my family of my willingness to donate.
At least one person appears to have indicated their opposition to transplantation in general.
Did you read this part of my reply?:
If this horrible thing was done to this woman's son then it needs to be made right
A person should NOT be killed for his/her organs, but if there's 0 percent chance of resusitation and - AND - the person has previously voluntarily opted for organ donorship, then his/her wishes should be carried out.
ping, in case you haven’t seen this one.
First let me say that you have my deepest sympathies, I could not imagine having to make that decision. But let me ask this, would you have agreed if she HAD NOT been brain dead?
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1804619/posts
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1717110/posts
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1665336/posts
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1657008/posts
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1650838/posts
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/734617/posts
“””The ignorance on this thread around the subject of organ donation and transplantation is astounding.”””
Opinions are just what they are.....like fruit. You pick what you like and ignore the others.
Try it!
Of course I wouldn’t agreed if she hadn’t been brain dead.
I felt fortunate we live in a state that requires three concurring opinions on declaration of brain death.
I was also fortunate in that her god-father - a devout practicing catholic who also is a cardiologist who has harvested hearts himself - - that he was allowed to witness the testing - evaluation of results - and consulted with the attending physicians.
I will NEVER sign an organ donor card. However, I have an advanced medical directive that makes it very clear that I wish to donate my organs.
Talk to any lawyer who specializes in these matters, they will tell you about the major differences between an attorney preparing medical directives and using boilerplate forms from a hospital or organ donor cards.
Many blacks won’t donate organs for this very reason.
You jerk. I hope you never ever need to have a kidney transplant. Try spending the rest of YOUR life on a dialysis machine, you fool.
“Many blacks won’t donate organs for this very reason”
Why?
What does being black have to do with it?
AMEN! I’m praying for a kidney.
They just don’t have a clue! Grrrrr.
Bless you, Scotswife. I know that was a difficult decision but you saved someone else’s life.
“””You jerk. I hope you never ever need to have a kidney transplant. Try spending the rest of YOUR life on a dialysis machine, you fool.”””
So Mary - you would like to make organ donation mandatory and not voluntary?
Show some respect for folks exercising their right to offer opinions and choice.
Thank you.
This paragraph brings up interesting questions about who was paying the bills and might add motive to the doctor’s being sued,
“The lawsuit alleges Roozrokh ordered Ruben Navarro be given lethal doses of morphine and Ativan, an accusation also reported as a finding in a federal investigation by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.