So a person's "track record" as let's say, a Satanist or Wicca advanced witch wouldn't really enter into your consideration, because that's "religious" and not "policy" or "public persona."
Oh, their track record would include personal things, such as do they sacrifice chickens during their religious ceremonies. But merely being an atheist, a satanist or a Wiccan wouldn't cause me to not vote for that person. It would be what they do with that belief that counts.