Giuliani lays out immigration plan to Latino group

The Hill | 5/1/07 | Chris Good

[sheana]

Undocumented immigrants who sign up for the pathway to citizenship should have to pay penalties and back taxes, and must demonstrate that they speak English, Giuliani said

Ummmmm Ruday, that’s still AMNESTY.

[KentTrappedInLiberalSeattle]

Giuliani wants undocumented workers to come forward and claim citizenship [...] Giuliani stopped short of calling this “amnesty,” however.

We have always been at war with Oceania.

[janetgreen]

His pandering speech sounds like it came right out of GW Bush's mouth. The LAST thing America needs is more insane policies like those of GW Bush.

America needs a president who puts America FIRST and makes rational decisions regarding America's future. We have been cheated of that for the last 18 years with the Bush/Clinton/Clinton/Bush/Bush regimes. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!

[Rastus]

Somebody cue up En Vogue’s “(My Vote) You’re Never Gonna Get It” for Rudy!

[WilliamofCarmichael]

pay penalties and back taxes

I heard Senator McCain say that he's opposed to these non-citizens being eligible to collect earned-income "refund" checks when they "pay" their back taxes.

What about the rest of the Senate? The House?

Non-citizens legally here are ineligible I believe but Hey! they followed the rules, the dummies.

[Titus Quinctius Cincinnatus]

Here’s the pathway to citizenship: Go home to where you came from, and apply for a green card through the U.S. Consulate, the same way everyone else does. Then, when you’ve been here legally for a number of years, and providing you’ve kept your nose clean, you can apply for citizenship, the same way everyone else does.

[raybbr]

His pandering speech sounds like it came right out of GW Bush's mouth. The LAST thing America needs is more insane policies like those of GW Bush.

The only thing he could have done to be more like Bush would have been to talk in spanish. I can't wait to hear Juliannie try a speech in spanish.

[tioga]

You are right, this is my biggest disappointment in GW Bush.

[dforest]

Continue to be disappointed. Rooty will not do anything any different from GWB, except maybe even more liberalism!

[tioga]

I agree, Rudy will not — BUT Hunter and Thompson offer me some hope.

[SmoothTalker]

RINO Rudy!

[spectre]

He wants amnesty. He doesn't respect the laws of this Nation anymore than the illegals do.

sw

[dforest]

I agree, Rudy will not — BUT Hunter and Thompson offer me some hope.

Well, I don't give up. I remain optimistic that the answer will be found. It's good thinking to hold a legit candidate back to keep from over exposure.

Fred, step in to restore sanity, soon.

[ken5050]

Related question for the group. When you become a naturalized citizen of the US, does your oath require you to give up of forgo citizenship in any other country?

[monkapotamus]

[Sloth]

“Of course we shouldn’t have amnesty,” the former mayor said. “People here legally should be at the front of the line.”

Uh, 1.) what you already described IS amnesty, and 2.) what about the people who stay in their native countries and go through proper channels to obtain entry to the U.S.? Where do they belong in "the line"?

[Ultra Sonic 007]

Ping.

[SWAMPSNIPER]

Shit, Rudy, can’t we breed our own democrats fast enough to please you?

[Beagle8U]

“Giuliani wants undocumented workers to come forward and claim citizenship “if they’re making an honest contribution.” He added that adherence to American ideals is what makes an American citizen, and that those who have come to the U.S. to make an honest living should be afforded official citizenship.”

Great Rooty, just tell them to sneak in and get a job and you’ll make them a brand new citizen.

I have a better Idea Rooty, you go to Mexico and live there.

You might find a village that needs an idiot!