Replies

Although one wonders if it's worth attempting to reason with you, there's nothing whatsoever Nazi-like about my comment ... as opposed to your blatantly anti-Catholic diatribe.

Aside from noting numerous apparently Jewish FReepers pinged the article - btw, written by a Jew who's a friendly acquaintance - without negative comment, let's look at what I essentially said:
Neither faith community is perfect, we should be free to fairly criticize each other & try to get along like the family we are.

"Although one wonders if it's worth attempting to reason with you, there's nothing whatsoever Nazi-like about my comment ... as opposed to your blatantly anti-Catholic diatribe."

Here are your words from your earlier post.

"I'd agree with you to the extent that it's fair & legitimate criticism of secular Jews to say they disingenuously & hypocritically use false charges of anti-Semitism to evade accountability for their self-evident racism, routine nepotism & generally pro-communist sympathies.

Surely, when we regularly see secular Jews (e.g. radical feminists) acting as apologists for Islamofascists, there's something awfully wrong with that picture - on multiple levels! - & political correctness, much less unconditional love, shouldn't preclude pointing it out?"

But let's rewrite your commentary and replace "Jews," as you put it, with Catholics, and "anti-semitism" with "anti-Catholic bigotry" (worn out phrase around here).

I'd agree with you to the extent that it's fair & legitimate criticism of secular Catholics to say they disingenuously & hypocritically use false charges of anti-Catholic bigotry to evade accountability for their self-evident racism, routine nepotism & generally pro-communist sympathies.

Surely, when we regularly see secular Catholics (e.g. radical feminists) acting as apologists for Islamofascists, there's something awfully wrong with that picture - on multiple levels! - & political correctness, much less unconditional love, shouldn't preclude pointing it out?

We all know as to the flames that would get from Catholics here, if it weren't a reply to your comments against Jews. So spare me your hypocritical Jew bashing and victimology on the part of your own religion.

I was a Christian, BTW, before the new propaganda war against the Jews was started by both leftists/liberals and conservatives in early 2004.

"...as opposed to your blatantly anti-Catholic diatribe."

The following was the only content about Catholics in my reply, and you called it an "anti-Catholic diatribe." Your accusation is incredible but is very frequently seen here.

From the CIA World Factbook (about the USA:
"Religions:
Protestant 52%, Roman Catholic 24%, Mormon 2%, Jewish 1%, Muslim 1%, other 10%, none 10% (2002 est.)"

Catholic Vote Swings Democratic in Midterm Elections
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1737011/posts

Congress more religiously diverse; Catholics still well represented [Most are C.I.N.O.'S]]
Catholic News Service/USCCB ^ | Jan-16-2007 | By Nancy Frazier O'Brien

"Catholics remain the largest denominational group in Congress, with 155 members -- 25 in the Senate and 130 in the House. But there are fewer Catholic Republicans in both houses since the 109th Congress and many more Catholic Democrats."

Catholicism Top Faith in U.S. Congress
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1763261/posts