Because even a 12-year-old voting on American Idol knows that if they really want to knock out a singer they can't stand, they have to VOTE FOR THE OTHER GUY.
You have the equivlent of coated two dung coated pigs, but you are telling me one smells better becuase it wears lipstick.
Hold your nose all you want but some smells are more pervasive than you give them credit for.