Replies

I couldn’t find anything either. In fact, there’s nothing, I repeat NOTHING, from Phil’s work on that campaign (or any other work he’s done elsewhere that I’ve tracked down) that even leaves one to hope that he is capable of the pure genius that is “Big Sister”. I remain skeptical.

Give me a break. The fact that this blogger was unable to find something is not proof that it doesn't exist. Did this blogger exhaustively review everything this guy ever did in his entire career? Did he review every homework assignment this guy did in film school (or where ever he got trained)?

With no training, as an amatuer, I could have done most of what is shown here in a couple of days. I've done more complicated things in editing home videos. My kids, in editing home movies, have come up with editing tricks more clever than exhibited here.

This was a competent editing job, reasonably well executed, no more and no less.

Even if it's shown this would have taken 2 days, so what? All that proves is that the guy exaggerates a bit in order to pad his resume.

I claimed in other posts, days ago, that this could have been done by a film student in a weekend using off the shelf editing software, and I stand by that assessment now.

People who claim this was some slick hollywood production that cost big bucks were clue-less from the beginning. People who do mashups on youtube know all these tricks, and considerably more, for making changes to existing material that look seemless.