Giuliani's brand of creeping socialism, by intent.
How dumb does someone have to be not to know that the heaviest smokers in the world are in socialist countries?
All the big commies were heavy smokers: Stalin, Mao, Ho, Castro, Huey Newton.
In advanced capitalist nations the smoking rate has plummeted. Only in Third World ratholes, European states and socialist havens are the numbers of smokers still high.