Posted on 03/08/2007 11:03:19 AM PST by Coleus
This morning at about 10 o'clock, Fox News broadcast a story about a family court judge in New Jersey who said he was "shocked" that homeschool families were not being "monitored," and said they should be. The anchorwoman and her guests gave the impression that the judge's opinion actually changed the law, and that now families would need to be monitored.
In fact, the judge did not change the law. Nothing has changed. In order to protect individual freedoms, the founders of our nation wanted to be sure that governmental power did not become overly concentrated. To prevent this, they wisely split power into three branches--legislative, judicial and executive. As the founders conceived it, the judicial branch has no power to make new laws. That power belongs to the legislature working through representatives elected by the people.
Even though the judge in this case said the homeschool laws of New Jersey should be different, it is not up to him to decide. The state of New Jersey already has laws on the books related to homeschooling, and this will only change if the people, through their elected representatives, enact a change. Furthermore, the judge's comments were "dicta"--legalese that means other judges are perfectly free to ignore the comments. Nothing the judge said in his written opinion is binding on any other judge or any other family.
The Fox News story overlooked one more important point. The judge allowed the mother to keep homeschooling--without being monitored. Even though the father had asked the judge to prohibit the mother from continuing the homeschool program, the judge's final order simply urged the parents to work out the issue among themselves, with recommendations of steps they should take to make sure the homeschool laws already on the books were obeyed. We don't expect a judge from one state to be familiar with the laws of other states. However, the judge might not have been shocked if he had been aware of the fact that New Jersey's homeschool law is similar to that of many other states.
Sincerely Yours, Scott A. Woodruff, HSLDA Staff Attorney
Ping for later
"Honerable", my Aunt Fannie...
...a family court judge in New Jersey who said he was "shocked" that homeschool families were not being "monitored," and said they should be.
----
Yes, the horrid enemies of the state, that home-schoolers are...why the very idea of the corrupt, dysfunctional government education system being trumped by a "free" citizen regarding the education of their OWN CHILDREN --- why that is just not good Marxism...such rebelious heresy must not go unpunished....
(Sounds like a line out of Star Wars from the Master of the Dark Side...)
home school
no wonder people are leaving the north in droves
Talk about liberal activists judges...
Thanks for posting!
The Mason Dixon line starts in New Jersey.
Sounds like this dad really cares about his kids.
That's why he's not there.
There's no way to determine what the children's test scores would have been, had they been taught at a school.
Apparently this lady *ahem* judge doesn't realize what a force homeschoolers are. Maybe she never heard of HR6 and what it did to wake up members of Congress.
not every mother is the best choice or capable of homeschooling. this father may have been helping her and without his help the kids may indeed be getting a substandard education.
"Honerable"
OK, that may not be the best advertisement for homeschooling, right there.....
Yes, isn't it amazing that New Jersey --of all places-- has been one of the most homeschool friendly states in the US?
I'm afraid that can only be because the Leftists here haven't gotten around to siccing the courts on homeschoolers...yet.
Hope this vindictive father doesn't ruin things for everyone in NJ by giving our hideously leftist courts (Abbott decision, arrgghh) a chance to meddle.
As a guvermint skooled persin, I must dissagree!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.