"How reasonable is reasonable?"
As a crusty old lawyer once said at a seminar, "The jury doesn't understand the jury instructions!"
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003554231
Juror Explains Libby Verdict: They Felt He Was 'Fall Guy'
By Greg Mitchell
Published: March 06, 2007 1:30 PM ET
NEW YORK A spokesman for the jury that convicted "Scooter" Lewis of four counts today of perjury and obstruction of justice today in a federal courtroom told reporters immediately afterward that many felt sympathy for Libby and believed he was only the "fall guy."
Denis Collins said, "We asked ourselves, what is HE doing here? Where is Rove and all these other guys....He was the fall guy."
He said they believed that Vice President Cheney did "ask him to talk to reporters."
He said, "some jurors said at one point, 'We wish we weren't judging Libby...this sucks."
Asked about Vice President Cheney not testifying, he said, "Having Cheney testifying would have been interesting." And when the defense opened the trial by suggesting that Libby was scapegoated by the White House, "I thought we might get to see President Bush here."
He also said that they found Tim Russert of NBC "very credible" and the defense "badgering" Judy Miller may have hurt them as some jurors developed "sympathy" for her. Even though she admitted having a "bad memory," the fact that she had notes counted a lot in her favor, he said.
(snip)