[M. Thatcher]

You can't have a productive intra-party fight with the extremist fringe.

I don't think it's intellectually honest or useful to demonize or dismiss those who have legitimate criticisms of Giuliani's positions.

It's the same fallacy many anti-Rudy posters use, dismissing Giuliani supporters as liberals and commies and such.

[NapkinUser]

I don't think it's intellectually honest or useful to demonize or dismiss those who have legitimate criticisms of Giuliani's positions.

It's the same fallacy many anti-Rudy posters use, dismissing Giuliani supporters as liberals and commies and such.

That is actually very reasonable.