How can you be sure he wouldnt carry his homestate? If McCain or Rommney is our boy we play defense on the Bush 2004 map with Hillary pouring all her money in Ohio, Arizona and New Mexico playing offense. Rudy turns the whole table around. Now Hillary is worrying about New Jersey and Penn. Rudy would make it extremly hard for Hillary to get Ohio, our Achilles heal in presidental elections. And according to that logic would you also agree Mitt Rommney will not be President?
I am certain that Rudy will not win his home state and that Mitt and McCain have a better chance of winning their home states.