Replies

The ALA review for the book you're citing says it's for Grade 11 and up (that's 16 or 17 and older) and that it's "best suited to mature readers".

Ok, folks. Help me to understand this. I see a growing review of Push on and ALA site. You are saying it's from an Amazon site, and the ALA somehow archived it.

If that were true, why would the ALA archive things not from its own site, and why would it archive things contradictory to its own site.

And the real damning evidence is that the top of the page is the "Teen Hoopla" logo for tha ALA's old, controversial Teen Hoopla site. So even if the reviews started on Amazon, the ALA felt fit to include them in its own body of work.

Now I do not know this for fact, at least not until I get to depose Judith Krug and the others, but that's the what it appears to me.

Do you have any information otherwise? I really want to know because I do not want to use incorrect arguments to support my claims--things are bad enough that I don't need to. There's plenty more where that came from.