Your comment was "too funny...12.3 billion = flat profits ". I assumed that your comment about flat profits at being $12.3 were sarcastic. That $12.3 billion was too much, and undeserved.
I was trying to make the point that when someone gets into business, first and foremost, profit must be made. If a consistant profit ratio is maintained, and business level remains constant or grows, bottom line profit will naturally go up.
In the case of oil, if profit growth was flat, while production was increasing, it shows that something negative was going on.
But the libs would only see the bottom line number, and not take into account other factors in the equation. And still make big oil an evil boogie man.