Replies

"This causes some trouble. We can't deport them all to either country, as neither country will take the other parent. Neither country really wants the american citizens either. The two have NO family in either country of origin, no place to live, no place to go to. "

Tough. Their home and business are fruits of the poisoned tree. There's an old expression: "hard cases make bad law". There are thousands of sob stories over taxes - if not millions. I don't see the government not enforcing the tax code because of them.

A national ID card will only be imposed against citizens and legal residents. What's more, it WILL be faked.

"Your plan for these people is simple -- even though they have paid their taxes, learned our language, and assimilated into our society, you must kick them out -- no exceptions. There are other people waiting in line that you would much rather have in the country than these people. "

Yes. That is the law. They (legals) do us the courtesy of ASKING to be let in and complying with our laws. Your example family did not. It's not as if they hasn't been a series of rolling amnesties ever since the 80s....