Skip to comments.
What You Can’t Smell Will Kill You
NY Times ^
| January 21, 2007
| LUCA TURIN
Posted on 01/23/2007 12:26:29 AM PST by neverdem
NOW that the mystery smells of Manhattan have abated, are you still wondering whether the Grim Reapers cologne will smell like maple syrup or rotten eggs when he comes for you?
Dont worry, because heres the thing: the more powerful the stench, the less likely it is to do harm. Indeed, the smell thats typically associated with natural gas is deliberately put in to warn you of its otherwise odorless presence youll call Con Edison before it all goes bang. In this case, it is not the thing that smells that will harm you, but the thing that doesnt smell.
As a kind of perverse perfumery, Chevron Phillips Chemical Company offers 24 different compositions of sulfur compounds as part of its Scentinel line of gas odorants. A few well-dispersed ounces of Scentinel A, which is made of ethyl mercaptan, the odorant added to natural gas, are enough to stink up all of Manhattan, but by themselves, they wont blow anything up.
So why do we find the sulfur smell by itself so objectionable? One hundred years ago, the most feared smells were those of putrefaction, which were thought to carry disease. These days, the chain of cold that takes perishables from fridge to fridge has all but eliminated smells of rot though many people still use the expression rotten egg smell, few have ever encountered it. Instead, what we fear today when we smell sulfur is the possibility that manufactured poisons are present.
In response to the widespread suspicion of smells, industry goes to great lengths to avoid generating them, and government agencies pay employees to scour the countryside to identify reported malodors. Nowadays, even huge fragrance plants like Symrises, which bestrides the bucolic town of Holzminden in central Germany, can be virtually odorless, thanks to better technology...
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
TOPICS: Culture/Society; Editorial; News/Current Events; US: New York
KEYWORDS: chemicals; naturalgas; njfarts; odors
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-23 next last
Luca Turin, a biophysicist and the head of technology for a perfume company, is the author of The Secret of Scent: Adventures in Perfume and the Science of Smell.IIRC, a sign of chemical attack is an abnormally large number of dead critters which should be obvious.
1
posted on
01/23/2007 12:26:30 AM PST
by
neverdem
To: neverdem
Dont worry, because heres the thing: the more powerful the stench, the less likely it is to do harm.And the NY Times is proof of that.
2
posted on
01/23/2007 12:29:40 AM PST
by
taxesareforever
(Never forget Matt Maupin)
To: neverdem
So we're safe around the Clintons?
3
posted on
01/23/2007 12:33:24 AM PST
by
Jeff Chandler
("... without victory there is no survival." - Winston Churchill)
To: Jeff Chandler
So we're safe around the Clintons? LOL, I learn something new every day.
4
posted on
01/23/2007 12:38:01 AM PST
by
Navy Patriot
(Zimbabwe, leftist success story.)
To: El Gato; Ernest_at_the_Beach; Robert A. Cook, PE; lepton; LadyDoc; jb6; tiamat; PGalt; Dianna; ...
5
posted on
01/23/2007 12:51:20 AM PST
by
neverdem
(May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
To: neverdem
...though many people still use the expression rotten egg smell, few have ever encountered it.Apparently this fellow hasn't experienced the "Monday Morning Mens Room" where he works.
To: neverdem
though many people still use the expression rotten egg smell, few have ever encountered it. Instead, what we fear today when we smell sulfur is the possibility that manufactured poisons are present.In all of the hype about that lingering odor I never heard once of the possibility of the aroma coming from H
2S.
Hydrogen Sulfide Gas - "Rotten Eggs"While extremely high levels of hydrogen sulfide can indeed be harmful, even deadly, H2S is one of those chemicals that can be detected by the nose at an extremely low level. In fact, it can be detected by the human nose at a concentration 1/400 times lower than the threshold for harmful human health effects.
To: neverdem
I don't smell anything unusual!!!! I'm Doomed! I must be dying!
Mark
8
posted on
01/23/2007 3:19:26 AM PST
by
MarkL
(When Kaylee says "No power in the `verse can stop me," it's cute. When River says it, it's scary!)
To: neverdem
Ooops...I stand corrected...
Sniffing Out the TruthThese gases include hydrogen sulfide and a variety of thiols (like the gas additives thiophane and mercaptan) all of which have an odor similar to rotten eggs.
To: neverdem; taxesareforever; Jeff Chandler; martin_fierro; Current Occupant; onyx; Miss Marple; ...
NOW that the mystery smells of Manhattan have abated, are you still wondering whether the Grim Reapers cologne will smell like maple syrup or rotten eggs when he comes for you? ....... Dont worry, because heres the thing: the more powerful the stench, the less likely it is to do harm. ****
"Thank God."
10
posted on
01/23/2007 4:08:27 AM PST
by
beyond the sea
( All lies and jest, still the man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest)
To: beyond the sea
I just figured that NYC pretty much always smelled like that.
L
11
posted on
01/23/2007 4:11:27 AM PST
by
Lurker
(Europeans killed 6 million Jews. As a reward they got 40 million Moslems. Karma's a bitch.)
To: Lurker
12
posted on
01/23/2007 4:14:34 AM PST
by
beyond the sea
( All lies and jest, still the man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest)
To: neverdem
A new spin on silent but deadly.
13
posted on
01/23/2007 4:26:42 AM PST
by
NonValueAdded
(Pelosi, the call was for Comity, not Comedy. But thanks for the laughs. StarKisses, NVA.)
To: this_ol_patriot
Nor did he ever ride in my old SUV in which a container of several dozen deviled eggs I was taking to a friend's house on a summer day slid off the seat onto the floor *plop* and all the scrubbing and sudsing and interior detailing in the world couldn't get rid of the "rotten egg smell."
Yes, I've smelled *real* rotten eggs AND mercaptan AND hydrogen sulfide gas AND Brays Bayou in Houston. All pretty much the same.
14
posted on
01/23/2007 5:18:48 AM PST
by
Rte66
To: neverdem
Ah, that explains it. I'm deathly allergic to most perfumes and I *can* smell them, too. He's a perfume guy, so thinks his *product* doesn't stink, lol.
15
posted on
01/23/2007 5:20:56 AM PST
by
Rte66
To: neverdem
Somebody needs to inform the Senate Ethics Committee.
16
posted on
01/23/2007 5:21:00 AM PST
by
tacticalogic
("Oh bother!" said Pooh, as he chambered his last round.)
To: neverdem
What you can't kill will smell you...
17
posted on
01/23/2007 5:22:05 AM PST
by
LIConFem
To: philman_36
H2S produces olfactory fatigue which makes it seem like the smell has gone away. This, along with its toxicity, is what makes it so dangerous.
If the smell was lingering it probably wasn't H2S.
18
posted on
01/23/2007 5:35:58 AM PST
by
Eagle Eye
(I'm a RINO because I'm too conservative to be a real Republican.)
To: neverdem; JoeSixPack1
![Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting](http://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a324/martin_fierro/ZOT/perfume_zot.jpg)
Friggin' perfumologists.
To: Lurker; beyond the sea
I just figured that NYC pretty much always smelled like that. Actually NYC only smells like that because of the odors drifting across from New Jersey's gas refineries!!! :-)
There is a refinery that is along old Route 66/I-55 just south of Joliet, IL. I know I'm getting close to Joliet (coming from the south) whenever I smell that refinery's output because the mercaptan or whatever else they put in that gas just PERMEATES the surrounding air.
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-23 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson