It is a false solution to real problems.
Oh?
It works for my family.
Have you tried it?
I wonder why increasingly more people are doing it. They must be really dumb to fall for this false solution of homeschooling. I'll bet their kids do really poorly, having been taught by dumb people. There are probably some statistics out there that show how poorly home-schooled kids do in college, etc.
In case you missed it: /sarc.
It's quite baseless to dismiss all homeschooling as ineffective, just as it is baseless to dismiss all public schooling as ineffective.
If you actually believe that most people who are homeschooling "shouldn't" be doing so (your word), that's astounding.
My children are receiving a world-class education and I am providing it.