The Theology of the Individual is as varied as there are Americans.. Everyone has a theology.. everyone.. Divorcing politics from theology is not possible.. its IMpossible..
You've jumped through as many semantic hoops avoiding answering that question as you did in constructing the original argument.
I've been thinking about that proposition, and I have a question. If I understand it correctly, by that standard every political decision, every vote, every law and piece of legislation is a question of morality. If I, or my representatives oppose a particular piece of legislation on the grounds that it is unconstitutional, that is a moral decision based on theology - it is religious. Under those conditions we cannot even require that our elected representatives swear an oath to uphold the Constitution without having violated the Constitution's proscription against requiring a religious test as a condition of holding public office. Are you sure you've thought this through?