I think you (and Judge Jones) misunderstood what Behe was saying.
"The only side to put forward a valid scientific analysis was the plaintiff."
Would that be the 'truth by popular opinion' analysis?
"You obviously haven't read the transcripts - the defense's star witness, under oath, admitted that ID is as scientific as astrology."
I think you (and Judge Jones) misunderstood what Behe was saying.
Well, I think that what Behe was saying is that for ID to be considered "science", the word would have to be defined down to include such things as astrology.
Cards on the table. What do you think he meant?