When I read the earlier thread, I assumed it was a complaint from some atheist activist.
That it's from a rabbi really pisses me off even more.
I'll reserve further judgment, but this is the last place I expected this challenge to come from.
A 'rabbi' I know of is an agnostic who does not believe in YHWH but gladly avails himself of the trappings and benefits of his position for selfish temporal gain. Of the same ilk as this rabbi, most likely, just less publicly a tool....
Merry Christmas Is NOT Offensive (Rabbi Daniel Lapin Urges Respect For Christian Holiday Alert)
Some of our good Jewish brethren need to take the Rabbi out behind the woodshed, get his attention with a two by four, and remind him that Christians aren't the enemy. It's the ragheads that are civilization's enemy.