[ahayes]

Then why are you acting as if his particular viewpoint is the only possible one science-minded people could accept? If Richard Dawkins is not God and does not dictate to us what we can and cannot think, than your post above was completely irrelevant.

[AndrewC]

Then why are you acting as if his particular viewpoint is the only possible one science-minded people could accept?

I never said it was the only one possible. I said you could not accept his particular viewpoint and hold the Pope's viewpoint. Do you?