[Peisistratus]

"So if you pay a "head tax" (non-muslim) you're ok? But in the next breath if you don't convert you die? They need to make up their minds."

Being a dhimmi was never OK. You were usually allowed to live another day, that's all.

[pieceofthepuzzle]

Exactly. Listen to what some Imams say it is OK to do to Kuffars.