[Steve_Seattle]

"Anything bad for the tyrants in the HOAs is good for America. This is a good law."

I think it's a serious mistake to see this law as a triumph for individual rights. It's a triumph of federal power over state and local rights, which only incidentally happens to favor individual homeowners in this case.

[mysterio]

In this case, the locality is tyranny and deserves to lose. In fact, I wouldn't mind seeing all mandatory HOAs dissolved and banned. All should be voluntary. It's not voluntary if you have to sign it as a condition of sale. If someone wants to sign away their property rights, then that's their business. But if they are forced to as a condition of the sale, that's wrong and should be stopped.