[TChris]

Because they are charging fees for it and therefore profit from the original work. If they did it for free then the studios would not have a case.

That doesn't wash either. Wal-Mart makes a profit by selling copies of the videos. Blockbuster makes a profit by renting them. Why shouldn't these businesses profit from the service of editing individual copies for content?

[Borges]

If you were a clothier and started altering designer clothes and selling them how long do you think it would take till Jordache or whoever knocked on your door?