You forget rudy's numerous affairs and personal life which reads like a triple x novel. That won't fly well.
Also remember rudy is short and bald. A 5'4 short balding rudy will look silly next to a 6'4 allen.
Rudy looks and acts like a leader. Allen just looks and acts like a dork. Rudy would make mincemeat out of Allen in a debate.
Bald? Sure.
Short? He's 6'2"...