[The Ghost of FReepers Past]

Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, writing for the majority, said Hispanics do not have a chance to elect a candidate of their choosing under the plan.

So it is fine if white Republicans are disadvantaged? That's unequal treatment. It seems wrong to see them as a group rather than as individuals. In voting, shouldn't it breaks down to equal individuals with different ideologies, not various voting blocks with equal representation.

[george wythe]

It seems wrong to see them as a group rather than as individuals.

Excellent point

For instance, creating school districts where blacks are segregated from whites is bad, according to liberal orthodoxy.

In contrast, creating Congressional districts where blacks are segregated from whites is good, according to liberal orthodoxy.

If you ever find a rational answer from a liberal to your excellent point, please ping me. I still don't understand why segregation is good sometimes, but it's bad at other times.