The sad fact is that we don't know how many illegals are here, where they work, how many receive EITC payments, pay into SS, pay taxes, receive social services, etc. How can you set good public policy without knowing the extent and breadth of the problem? Secure our borders and enforcement of our existing laws first before cmprehensive immigration reform.
No arguement here with the basic premise of both your posts.
Just want people to keep in mind their is an economic benefit to our economy from the illegals as well as costs.
Here is what we should be doing.
1. Enforce the border. (Do this now)
2. Get a grip on just how many illegals ARE here. (Probably require 2-3 years of concentrated effort)
3. Decide on some sort of "Guest worker" or expanded Immigration based on the economic effects seen from 1 and 2.
Sorry to say the Politics from President Bush have been all messed up. Requiring "Comprehsnesive Immigration Reform" is the same sort of "give me all or nothing" mindset that gets legilsative inititves kills in Congress.
If he had started on issue 1 say 4 years ago right after 9-11 then was moving to 2 now, he might of had a shot at doing 3 before he leaves office. Now I fear NOTHING will get done except until we get a serious Senate Leader to replace Frist.
If the Repbs hold the Senate anyone know who will replace Frist as Majority Leader who is retiring?