Do you honestly believe that this is a fair article?
On balance, I think that it captures the more salient points rather well. It is the luck of the draw as far as what events you are given to deal with when elected president. I believe that GWB has done as good a job as many, not as well as some, and far, far better than either Algore or Kerry would have. He is not perfect, by any means, but we could have done much worse.
As to whether or not it is fair, I am not sure exactly what you mean by fair, but I don't think that fair really enters into the equation; unless,by fair, you mean that it was only fairly well written.